Let’s face it — protein shakes are a vibe. Whether you’re recovering from a workout, skipping a sad desk lunch, or just trying to sneak more nutrients into your day, a protein shake can be the ultimate healthy hack. But creating the perfect one? That takes a little science, a little creativity… and a really good blender.
In this guide, we’re breaking down everything you need to know about how to make a protein shake — from crafting your own protein shake recipes to choosing the best ingredients. (Spoiler alert: If all of this sounds like a lot, The Fresh Monkee has you covered.)
🧱 The Building Blocks of a Great Protein Shake
The best protein shakes recipes start with a simple formula. Think of it like a smoothie equation:
Protein + Liquid + Produce + Healthy Fat + Flavor Boosters + Ice = Shake Glory
💪 Step 1: Choose Your Protein Wisely
This is the backbone of any protein shake recipe. It fuels your body, supports recovery, and keeps you full.
Top picks:
- Whey protein isolate (fast-absorbing + low carb)
- Plant-based protein (pea, brown rice, or hemp)
- Collagen protein (for hair, skin, joints)
- Greek yogurt or cottage cheese (protein + creaminess)
✅ At The Fresh Monkee, we offer high-quality whey and plant-based protein options in all our shakes.
Learn more: Why protein is essential
🥛 Step 2: Add the Right Liquid
Your liquid sets the tone for taste and texture.
Top options:
- Almond milk (Benefits)
- Oat milk (Pros)
- Coconut water (electrolyte boost)
- Dairy milk (protein-rich and classic)
- Cold brew (caffeine + flavor) – YES! We have coffee options too!
Skip sugary juices — they spike your shake’s sugar levels and defeat the purpose of a clean blend.
🍌 Step 3: Add Fresh Fruit and Veggies
Produce brings fiber, flavor, antioxidants, and bulk to your shake. Want to know how to make a protein shake that’s not just tasty but nourishing? Start here.
Best fruits:
- Strawberries (See why they’re a superfruit)
- Bananas (for texture and potassium)
- Pineapple (Benefits)
- Watermelon (Hydration & nutrients)
Top veggies:
- Spinach (Nutrient powerhouse)
- Kale (Loaded with vitamins)
- Zucchini or cauliflower (great hidden add-ins!)
✅ All of these are used in our signature shakes — no added sugar, ever.
🥜 Step 4: Healthy Fats FTW
Fats help you feel full and absorb key nutrients.
Monkee-approved sources:
- Natural peanut butter (Benefits)
- Almond butter
- Chia seeds or flaxseeds
- Coconut oil
- Avocado
✅ We use only the highest-quality nut butters in our shakes, never sweetened or processed.
🍫 Step 5: Sweeten Smart
A protein shake doesn’t need to taste like punishment. Keep it natural:
Best sweeteners:
- Medjool dates
- Monk fruit or stevia
- Vanilla extract or cinnamon
- Unsweetened cocoa or dark chocolate (Why it’s good)
At The Fresh Monkee, we skip the syrups and sweeten with real food.
🌀 Step 6: Blend Like a Pro
Want smooth, creamy shakes? It’s all about technique:
- Add liquids first
- Follow with protein, produce, and extras
- Use a high-speed blender (like a protein shaker, but better!)
- Don’t over-blend — 30 to 60 seconds is perfect
✅ Not into cleaning your blender? We got you covered. Order your shake and skip the mess.
📋 Sample Protein Shake Recipe: Monkee-Style
Want a DIY version of a Fresh Monkee fave? Here’s a home-friendly recipe:
The DIY Chunky Monkee
- 1 scoop chocolate whey protein
- 1 cup unsweetened almond milk
- ½ frozen banana
- 1 tbsp natural peanut butter
- 1 tsp cocoa powder
- Handful of spinach
- Ice to taste
Blend until smooth — and enjoy the protein-packed power!
Need more protein shake recipes? Browse our shake menu — each flavor was crafted for flavor and function.
🕒 When to Drink a Protein Shake
Not sure when to use a protein shaker or visit Fresh Monkee? Here are the prime times:
- Post-workout (within 30 minutes) – you can drink you protein shake before or after workout!
- As a healthy lunch or meal replacement
- For energy on the go
- When cravings hit hard
Google searching “protein shakes recipes” at 3 p.m.? Just pop by your local Fresh Monkee.
🤹♀️ Too Busy to Blend? We Got You.
We love a good DIY moment, but we also know life is busy. That’s why we built The Fresh Monkee — to deliver premium protein shake recipes without the blender cleanup.
✅ No added sugar
✅ No fillers
✅ Always made-to-order
✅ Always customizable
Find your closest location and let us take care of the shake magic.
🧠 Final Sip
So, want to know how to make a protein shake that hits every mark? Start with high-quality ingredients, use a smart blend of macros, and follow flavor with function. And if you want one already done to perfection? We’re here.
📋 Check our story
🥤 Explore our shakes
📍 Find us
📬 Reach out for questions or feedback
